Question 1

What is an ideal body weight?

Accepted Answer

Ideal body weight (IBW) is an estimated weight range considered healthiest for your height, age, and gender. It is not a single number but a range derived from scientific formulas. Our calculator uses four established formulas — Robinson, Miller, Devine, and Hamwi — and averages them for a balanced estimate. Ideal weight is a guide, not a strict target, and should be considered alongside body fat percentage, muscle mass, and overall health.

Question 2

What are the Robinson, Miller, Devine, and Hamwi formulas?

Accepted Answer

These are four scientifically established methods for estimating ideal weight: Robinson (1983) is most common in clinical settings; Devine (1974) was originally developed for drug dosing calculations; Miller (1983) tends to give slightly higher estimates; and Hamwi (1964) is one of the earliest ideal weight formulas. Each uses height and gender as inputs but applies different coefficients, which is why results vary slightly between them.

Question 3

How much should I weigh for my height?

Accepted Answer

Ideal weight varies by height and gender. For example, a 5'4" woman's ideal weight ranges from approximately 108–138 lbs (49–63 kg), while a 5'10" man's ideal weight is approximately 149–183 lbs (68–83 kg). These are general ranges — your personal ideal weight depends on factors including body frame size, muscle mass, age, and overall health. Use our calculator for a personalized estimate based on your specific height.

Question 4

Is there a difference between ideal weight for men and women?

Accepted Answer

Yes — ideal weight formulas produce different results for men and women at the same height because of natural differences in body composition. Men typically have greater muscle mass and bone density, resulting in higher ideal weight estimates. For example, at 5'8", the ideal weight for a man is approximately 154 lbs while for a woman it's approximately 140 lbs. These differences reflect biological variations, not fitness levels.

Question 5

Why does my ideal weight differ from my goal weight?

Accepted Answer

Your ideal weight (calculated by scientific formulas) and goal weight (what you personally want to weigh) may differ for several reasons. Goal weight might be influenced by aesthetic preferences, athletic requirements, or past weight history. A bodybuilder's goal weight may be well above their calculated ideal weight. The key is that your target should fall within a healthy BMI range (18.5–24.9) and be sustainable long-term.

Question 6

Can your ideal weight change as you age?

Accepted Answer

While the formulas themselves don't account for age, the practically healthy weight range shifts slightly with age. Adults over 65 may benefit from slightly higher body weight (BMI 23–27) as moderate weight provides protection against osteoporosis and provides reserves during illness. Conversely, younger adults at the higher end of the range face more long-term health risk. Maintaining muscle mass through strength training is more important than chasing a specific number.

Question 7

How does body frame size affect ideal weight?

Accepted Answer

Body frame size (small, medium, or large) can shift your ideal weight by 10–15%. People with larger frames have heavier bones and naturally carry more weight at the same height. You can estimate frame size by wrapping your thumb and index finger around your wrist: if they overlap, you have a small frame; if they just touch, medium; if they don't touch, large. Larger-framed individuals should target the higher end of the ideal weight range.

Question 8

What is the healthiest rate of weight loss to reach ideal weight?

Accepted Answer

The recommended rate of weight loss is 1–2 pounds (0.5–1 kg) per week for most adults. This rate preserves muscle mass, prevents metabolic adaptation, and is easier to sustain long-term. Faster weight loss through crash diets often results in muscle loss, nutritional deficiencies, gallstones, and rapid weight regain. If you need to lose more than 50 lbs, a rate of 2 lbs per week under medical supervision may be appropriate.

Question 9

Should I focus on ideal weight or ideal body composition?

Accepted Answer

Body composition (the ratio of muscle, fat, and bone) is a better health indicator than weight alone. Two people at the same weight can have vastly different health profiles — one with high muscle and low fat, the other with low muscle and high fat. Focus on body fat percentage (healthy range: 10–20% for men, 18–28% for women), waist circumference, and physical fitness metrics alongside your weight goal.

Question 10

How does ideal weight relate to BMI?

Accepted Answer

The healthy BMI range of 18.5–24.9 defines a weight range for any given height. Ideal weight formulas typically produce results within this BMI range. For a 5'9" person, a BMI of 18.5 corresponds to about 125 lbs and 24.9 corresponds to about 169 lbs. The ideal weight formulas generally target the middle of this range. If your calculated ideal weight gives a BMI outside 18.5–24.9, prioritize the BMI-healthy range as your target.

Ideal Weight Calculator

About These Formulas

More Health Tools

Ideal Weight Calculator FAQ